Case Studies

Lead re-engagement case study: investment software leads

An investment software firm let an AI agent reopen 2,009 leads that had said no. It built $450K in pipeline, and one sale paid for it five times over.

Updated 17 November 2026 3 min read
$450K
In pipeline from leads that had said no
5x+
Return from a single sale
1 in 4
Leads who had said no replied
A field of small dots on a dark navy background, about a quarter lit blue and a few glowing amber

An investment software firm reopened 2,009 leads its team had already called and lost, and built $450,000 in sales pipeline from people who had said no. Almost one in four replied to the AI agent, 30 asked the firm to get in touch, and a single sale returned more than five times what the campaign cost.

Why leads who said no are still worth contacting

The firm sells investment analysis software to individual investors. Its sales team works leads by phone, and over time it had built up a long list of people it had called who had said no, for reasons like timing or not being sure it was for them.

That list sat untouched. Calling people who have already turned you down is slow, uncomfortable work, and nobody on the team had time for it.

How the AI agent re-engages leads who declined

We built an agent that texts each declined lead under the firm’s own persona. It reminds them that they spoke about the software a while back, follows up a few times over about a month, and gives them something new to react to, such as how the software has changed since they last spoke. When they reply, it deals with what they actually say, whether that is money, timing or doubt, and books a walkthrough with the team when they are open to one.

What a re-engagement text to a declined lead looks like

This lead had ignored three messages over about a month. Names and the business are hidden.

Agent: Hey [name], Kiara from [firm]. Been a month. Curious whether this is something you are still weighing up.

Lead: Yes and no. Still concerned about the unknown & when something is too good to be true, I get curious.

Agent: I understand why it might sound that way. Happy to show you the independently verified data rather than ask you to take my word for it. Verified numbers do not need much explaining.

Lead: Can set up some time on Wednesday mid-morning if that works.

The walkthrough was booked for Wednesday at 10am his time. Another lead in this campaign said money was tight until the middle of next year, and still asked for a call the next afternoon once the agent made clear it was a walkthrough, not a sales push. Both threads are on our real conversations page.

Lead re-engagement results: $450K in pipeline

ResultFigure
Sales pipeline from leads that had said no$450,000
Return from a single saleMore than five times what the campaign cost
Leads who had said no and repliedAlmost one in four
People who asked to be contacted30: they rang in, booked a call, or asked for a call or an email
Hours the sales team spent re-calling the listNone

How these are worked out: replies and requests come from the client’s CRM. Pipeline values each of the 30 people who asked to be contacted at the firm’s average sale of about $15,000. The return compares one average sale with what the campaign cost. The firm wants to keep the campaign running.

How to re-engage old leads who said no

Treat a “no” as a “not now”, because that is usually what it is. Money comes back, timing changes and doubts fade, but nobody on a sales team has time to keep checking in with people who turned them down. An agent does, and it only takes one sale to pay for it.

The two things that worked here were patience and a new reason to talk. The agent kept going for a month, and each follow-up gave the lead something different to respond to instead of repeating the same pitch.

You can see how this works on our database reactivation page and our re-engagement page. To find out what your own list of old leads could be worth, book a free revenue engine audit.

Common questions

Frequently asked questions

Is it worth contacting leads who already said no?

For this investment software firm it was. Its team had already called 2,009 leads who said no. When an AI agent texted them, 24.5% replied, 30 asked to be contacted, and a single sale at the firm's average value returned more than five times what the campaign cost.

Why would someone who said no reply to a text?

People say no for reasons that change: money is tight, the timing is wrong, or they did not trust the product yet. A text that acknowledges the earlier no and offers something new, such as what has changed since, gives them an easy way back.

How many follow-ups does it take?

Several. In this campaign some of the best replies came to the fourth message, about a month after the first.

Share
Your turn

See what this looks like inside your business.

We map where your leads go quiet, then show you the conversations an agent would have had. Thirty minutes, no obligation.